ThinkProgress observed:
Despite this supposed weakening of the language, the new bill does not seem to be all that accommodating:
Marriage between one man and one woman is the only domestic legal union that shall be valid or recognized in this State. This section does not prohibit a private party from entering into contracts with another private party; nor does this section prohibit courts from adjudicating the rights of private parties pursuant to such contracts.If one-man/one-woman marriage is still the “only domestic legal union” that will be recognized, how exactly does the additional language leave room for domestic partnerships? Law professors have condemned it as “vague and untested,” suggesting it may even “invalidate domestic violence protections” for unmarried couples.
Against placing constitutional amendment to ban all gay legal unions on ballot in North Carolina: Atwater, Berger, D., Blue, Clodfelter, Dannelly, Garrou, Graham, Jenkins, Jones, Kinnaird, McKissick, Nesbitt, Purcell, Robinson, Stein, Vaughan
For placing constitutional amendment to ban all gay legal unions on ballot in North Carolina: Allran Apodaca, Berger, P., Bingham, Blake, Brock, Brown, Brunstetter, Clary, Daniel, Davis, East, Forrester, Goolsby, Gunn, Harrington, Hise, Hunt, Jackson, Meredith, Newton, Pate, Preston, Rabon, Rouzer, Rucho, Soucek, Stevens, Tillman, Tucker
Absent: Hartsell, Mansfield, Walters, White
Here is how the North Carolina House voted on the same issue yesterday:
1295 SB514 | DEFENSE OF MARRIAGE. Sponsor: BRUNSTETTER Third Reading | Outcome: PASSED Time: Sep 12 2011 6:02PM |
Total Votes: 117 Ayes: 75 Noes: 42 Not: 2 Exc. Absent: 1 Exc. Vote: 0
Democrat | Republican | |
Ayes: | Representative(s): Brisson; Crawford; Floyd; Goodman; Graham; Hill; McGuirt; Owens; Pierce; Spear | Representative(s): Avila; Barnhart; Blackwell; Blust; Boles; Brawley; Brown, L.; Brown, R.; Brubaker; Burr; Cleveland; Collins; Cook; Current; Daughtry; Dixon; Dockham; Dollar; Faircloth; Folwell; Frye; Gillespie; Guice; Hager; Hastings; Hilton; Hollo; Holloway; Howard; Hurley; Iler; Ingle; Johnson; Jones; Jordan; Justice; Killian; Langdon; LaRoque; Lewis; McComas; McCormick; McElraft; McGee; Mills; Moffitt; Moore, T.; Murry; Pridgen; Randleman; Sager; Saine; Samuelson; Sanderson; Setzer; Shepard; Stam; Starnes; Steen; Stevens; Stone; Tillis (SPEAKER); Torbett; Warren, H.; West |
Noes: | Representative(s): Adams; Alexander, K.; Alexander, M.; Bell; Bordsen; Brandon; Bryant; Carney; Cotham; Earle; Faison; Farmer-Butterfield; Fisher; Gill; Glazier; Hackney; Haire; Hall; Hamilton; Harrison; Insko; Jackson; Jeffus; Keever; Lucas; Luebke; Martin; McLawhorn; Michaux; Mobley; Moore, R.; Parfitt; Parmon; Rapp; Ross; Tolson; Wainwright; Warren, E.; Weiss; Wilkins; Womble; Wray | Representative(s): None |
Not Voting: | Representative(s): None | Representative(s): Bradley; McGrady |
Exc. Absence: | Representative(s): None | Representative(s): Horn |
No comments:
Post a Comment